Wolfram Prompt Repository(Under Construction)
A curated collection of prompts, personas, functions & more for LLMs (large language model AIs)
ThinkingHatsFeedback
Feedback by wearing different idea hats
Chat Example
!ThinkingHatsFeedback |  |
Heart of the Matter:Tariffs are taxes on imported goods, paid by the importer, with rare exceptions where they are levied on exported goods and paid by the exporter. These taxes serve as revenue for the government and can be used to protect domestic industries by making foreign goods more expensive. They aim to encourage local production, reduce trade deficits, safeguard new industries, and counter unfair pricing practices like dumping or currency manipulation.
Hat Name | Perspective | Feedback | New Ideas |
White | Information and Facts | Tariffs are demonstrably a source of government revenue and can impact the prices of goods. Data on past tariff implementations and their effects on specific industries and consumer prices should be researched to understand the practical consequences. Consider the elasticity of demand for the affected goods, as this will influence the effectiveness of the tariff. | Conduct an in-depth analysis of historical tariff implementations and their economic outcomes, focusing on specific industries and countries, Research the current trade agreements and how tariffs would affect these agreements, Examine the potential impact of tariffs on consumer prices and overall inflation rates. |
Black | Judgement and Caution | Tariffs can lead to retaliatory actions from other countries, resulting in trade wars and economic damage to all parties involved. They increase costs for consumers and businesses that rely on imported goods, potentially hindering economic growth. Protective tariffs shield inefficient domestic industries from competition, reducing innovation and productivity. | Assess the potential for retaliatory tariffs from other countries and their impact on domestic industries, Analyze the potential increase in consumer prices and its effect on purchasing power, Evaluate the risk of creating inefficient domestic industries that rely on protectionism. |
Gray | Cynicism and Skepticism | Tariffs are often presented as a solution to complex economic problems, but they are frequently used to benefit specific industries or political interests at the expense of the general public. The claim that tariffs protect infant industries is often a smokescreen for cronyism and rent-seeking. Expect politicians to take credit for any perceived positive effects while blaming external factors for negative outcomes. | Investigate the lobbying efforts and political contributions of industries that stand to benefit from tariffs, Scrutinize the justifications for protecting "infant industries" and assess their long-term viability, Anticipate political spin and manipulation of economic data to support the implementation of tariffs. |
Red | Feelings and Emotion | The idea of protecting local jobs and industries evokes a sense of national pride and security. However, the potential for increased prices and reduced choices can lead to frustration and resentment among consumers. The fairness of tariffs is questionable, as they disproportionately affect lower-income individuals who rely on affordable imported goods. | Gauge public sentiment towards tariffs through surveys and focus groups, emphasizing both the potential benefits and drawbacks, Frame the debate around tariffs in terms of fairness and equity, considering the impact on different socioeconomic groups, Acknowledge the emotional appeal of protecting local jobs while addressing concerns about consumer costs and choices. |
Yellow | Benefits and Creativity | Tariffs can incentivize domestic production, leading to job creation and economic growth within the country. They can also encourage innovation as domestic companies strive to compete with foreign products. Tariffs can provide a strategic advantage in negotiations with other countries, allowing for more favorable trade agreements. | Explore opportunities to use tariffs as a catalyst for innovation and technological advancement in domestic industries, Identify specific sectors where tariffs could create new jobs and stimulate economic growth, Consider using tariffs as a bargaining chip in trade negotiations to secure more favorable terms for domestic businesses. |
Green | Profitability and Potential | Tariffs can create new revenue streams for the government, which can be used to fund public services or reduce other taxes. They can also increase the profitability of domestic industries by reducing competition from foreign companies. The potential for tariffs to attract foreign investment as companies seek to avoid import taxes by establishing local production facilities. | Analyze the potential revenue generation from tariffs and its impact on government finances, Identify specific industries where tariffs could significantly increase profitability and market share for domestic companies, Explore opportunities to attract foreign investment by offering incentives for companies to establish local production facilities. |
Blue | Usefulness and Opportunities | Tariffs can be a useful tool for addressing specific trade imbalances or unfair trade practices. They can also be used to promote specific policy goals, such as environmental protection or labor rights. The opportunity to use tariffs as a temporary measure to allow domestic industries to adapt to changing global market conditions. | Develop clear criteria for when and how tariffs should be used, ensuring they are targeted and effective, Explore the potential for using tariffs to promote environmental sustainability and fair labor practices in international trade, Consider using tariffs as a temporary measure to support domestic industries during periods of transition or economic disruption. |
Purple | Assessment and Direction | The perspectives highlight the complex and multifaceted nature of tariffs. While tariffs can generate revenue, protect domestic industries, and promote policy goals, they also carry risks of retaliation, increased costs for consumers, and reduced innovation. The direction should be a careful and evidence-based approach to tariff implementation, considering both the potential benefits and drawbacks. A thorough analysis of the specific industry, the potential for retaliation, and the impact on consumers is essential before implementing tariffs. | Conduct a comprehensive cost-benefit analysis of any proposed tariff, considering all stakeholders, Develop a clear and transparent process for tariff implementation, with opportunities for public input and review, Establish mechanisms for monitoring the effectiveness of tariffs and adjusting policies as needed. |
Programmatic Access
LLMResourceFunction["ThinkingHatsFeedback"][txt] gives a summary and table of the text txt. | |
LLMResourceFunction["ThinkingHatsFeedback"][txt,hs] gives the hats table only for the hats hs. | |
LLMResourceFunction["ThinkingHatsFeedback"][txt,hs,fmt] gives the hats table in format fmt. |
Examples
Here is an idea:
In[1]:=
text="A donut shop that is open during the night.";
Here the feedback is obtained:
In[2]:=
res=LLMResourceFunction["ThinkingHatsFeedback"][text];
Here the Markdown LLM-result is converted to notebook cell(s):
In[3]:=
ResourceFunction["ImportMarkdownString"][res]
Out[3]=
Summary: The idea is to open a donut shop that operates exclusively or primarily during nighttime hours, catering to customers who seek fresh donuts late at night.
Hat | Perspective | Feedback | New Ideas |
White | Information and Facts | Nighttime-only food services target a niche market; most food businesses operate during the day or early evening. Data shows some demand for late-night snacks, especially near entertainment districts or workplaces with night shifts. Key factors include location, staffing, and supply chain reliability during off-hours. | Research local competitors’ hours, analyze foot traffic and night-time demand, partner with 24/7 delivery platforms. |
Black | Judgement and Caution | Running a shop at night raises concerns about low foot traffic in some areas, increased security risks, higher labor costs for night shifts, and potential difficulty sourcing fresh ingredients. There might be legal restrictions or higher costs for night operations. | Conduct a risk assessment for crime/weather conditions, check local regulations, consider cost analysis for night shifts. |
Gray | Cynicism and Skepticism | A nighttime donut shop might just be an attempt to create “exclusivity” or capitalize unnecessarily on late-night cravings. Is this a genuine need or a marketing ploy? Also, staffing might be sold as “cool” but could exploit low-wage, tired workers. Will the product quality or customer experience suffer at odd hours? | Beware of overhyping the concept, scrutinize staff welfare, question if this is a niche gimmick or sustainable business. |
Red | Feelings and Emotion | There’s a comforting, cozy feeling about having access to fresh donuts when everything else is closed—this taps into nostalgia and late-night indulgence. The idea feels friendly and inviting, potentially creating a loyal community of night owls and college students. | Create a warm, welcoming late-night atmosphere, use emotional marketing emphasizing comfort, run special “midnight donut” events. |
Yellow | Benefits and Creativity | Nighttime operations fill a market gap, appealing to shift workers, party-goers, and late-night cravings. The novelty could attract media attention and social buzz. Creativity could expand to donut flavors inspired by night themes or collaborations with late-night bars. | Develop unique “night owl” flavors, partner with clubs or theaters for promotions, offer delivery tailored to late-night demand. |
Green | Profitability and Potential | The nighttime window could reduce competition, commanding higher prices during limited hours. Happy hour-style deals may boost volume. Additionally, selling complementary products (coffee, energy drinks) can increase ticket size. However, profitability depends heavily on location and fixed costs. | Consider subscription models for late-night consumers, develop wholesale partnerships with convenience stores, explore branded merchandise targeting night customers. |
Blue | Usefulness and Opportunities | This concept serves unmet needs of nocturnal workers and leisure crowds. Opportunities include 24-hour events, food truck extensions for festivals, or pop-ups near nightlife hubs. Integrating tech for pre-orders and contactless delivery could increase ease. | Utilize app-based ordering with incentives for repeat customers, expand to mobile pop-ups near major night events, integrate nightlife partnerships for cross-promotion. |
Purple | Assessment and Direction | The idea meets a precise market need but faces operational and security challenges. Success hinges on careful location selection, strong branding targeting night crowds, and risk mitigation. A phased launch with pop-ups or delivery focus could test viability. Emphasize employee safety and customer experience to build trust and differentiation. | Pilot in nightlife-heavy areas first, invest in safety measures, focus on strong community engagement, diversify offerings to maximize revenue streams. |
Scope (2)
Scope
(2)
Define a text:
In[1]:=
text="Reverse Zoo";
Specify the focus hats:
In[2]:=
res=LLMResourceFunction["ThinkingHatsFeedback"][text,"Yellow, Blue"]
Out[2]=
The Reverse Zoo concept involves creating a space where animals roam freely in a naturalistic environment while humans observe them from enclosures or safe vantage points. This innovative approach aims to promote animal welfare, provide a more enriching experience for the animals, and engage visitors in a unique way. | Hat Name | Perspective | Feedback | New Ideas ||------------|-----------------------------------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|---------------------------------------------|| Yellow Hat | Benefits and Creativity | The Reverse Zoo presents numerous benefits; it highlights animal behavior in a natural setting, enhances visitor engagement, and can foster a deeper understanding of conservation. People may feel more connected to wildlife when they see them in a space that mimics their natural habitat. | Create themed experiences based on habitats, Implement educational programs, Develop virtual tours for remote accessibility || Blue Hat | Usefulness and Opportunities | This concept has significant potential; it could revolutionize how people interact with wildlife. Opportunities for partnerships with educational institutions, conservation organizations, and tourism agencies exist. Additionally, technological integration such as augmented reality could enhance visitor experience and engagement. | Develop interactive apps for visitor education, Host conservation-focused events, Create memberships for regular visits and community involvement |
Define an idea as text:
In[3]:=
tarText=
;StringTake[tarText,300]
Out[3]=
A tariff or import tax is a duty imposed by a national government, customs territory, or supranational union on imports of goods and is paid by the importer. (Exceptionally, an export tax may be levied on exports of goods or raw materials and is paid by the exporter.) Besides being a source of reven
The default value of the second, "focus hats" argument is . Other values can be strings or list of strings. (Each string being a hat name.) The default value of the third, table format argument is "Markdown". Other common values are "HTML" and "JSON". Here is an example with the table being for Yellow and Gray hats only and in "JSON" format:
In[4]:=
res2=LLMSynthesize@LLMPrompt["ThinkingHatsFeedback"][tarText,{"yellow","gray"},"JSON"];StringLength[res2]
Out[4]=
2074
The following function converts wider range of LLM results obtained by requests to generate JSON code:
In[5]:=
Clear[FromJSON];FromJSON[t_String]:=Block[{tj=StringCases[t,"```json"~~x:Shortest[___]~~"```"x]//First},ImportString[FromCharacterCode@ToCharacterCode[tj,"UTF-8"],"RawJSON"]];
Here the JSON result is converted into a dataset:
In[6]:=
ResourceFunction["GridTableForm"][Dataset[Association/@FromJSON[res2]]/.{x_StringStyle[x,FontFamily"Times New Roman"]}]
Out[6]=
# | hat | perspective | feedback | new_ideas |
1 | Yellow | Benefits and creativity | Tariffs can effectively stimulate local industries, foster innovation in domestic manufacturing, and reduce dependence on foreign suppliers, especially in strategic sectors. They also encourage the development of new products tailored to local markets and can create opportunities for job growth within protected industries. | Explore tariffs as a tool to promote green technologies domestically, use tariff revenues to fund vocational training programs, implement dynamic tariffs that incentivize sustainable production practices |
2 | Gray | Cynicism and skepticism | Tariffs often mask protectionism disguised as economic patriotism, potentially paving the way for rent-seeking behaviors by domestic industries lobbying for continuous favors. They can be exploited by politicians to score short-term popularity at the expense of consumers who bear higher prices, and may trigger retaliatory trade wars disguised as economic defense. | Investigate who truly benefits from tariffs beyond stated goals, analyze the role of corporate lobbying in tariff policy, scrutinize tariffs as political tools during election cycles |
Properties and Relations (1)
Properties and Relations
(1)
External Links
Prompt Source
Source Metadata
- Citation:
See Also
Publisher Information
- Contributed by: Anton Antonov
Author Notes
A seventh, Gray hat was added for cynical and sceptical thinking. An eighth, Purple hat was added for "assessment and direction" that takes into account all other hats feedback.